Thursday, 22 April 2010

Book Review: The Namesake [Audio Book]

the namesake

The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri

Narrated by Sarita Choudhury

Category: Fiction

Challenges: South Asian Author Challenge

Synopsis: The Namesake is the story of a family from India who come to America. Although the story starts by telling of Ashoke and Ashima, the young married couple, most of the story is about their son, initially named Gogol but who later changes his name to Nikhil.

My Thoughts: This book left me feeling a bit disappointed. I liked the language in the story. Lahiri always writes such beautiful prose and to a certain extent I connected with the characters but I just felt a bit let down by the end I think. Now I know that Lahiri doesn’t always write happy endings and it wasn’t necessarily that which bothered me. I think it was just the rather abrupt ending. The final scene was good but had it not been for the fact that I saw the timestamp I wouldn’t necessarily have known it was over soon. It just jumped up on you somehow.

I did connect with Gogol/Nikhil with regards to the name issue. My name is unusual in Sweden but common in English speaking countries. Growing up I really hated always having to spell it. I was the kid who would pre-empt the sub by saying “that’s me” when I knew they were coming to my name. In that respect I understood his frustrations. However, I didn’t like the way he treated his parents after he found out. He never really acknowledged what his father did until it was to late. Maybe I am sensitive to this because I almost lost my dad over the summer (there but for the grace…). For me, the thought of my father not being here is enough to change my view on life. For Gogol/Nikhil finding out about his fathers accident seems to have no effect what so ever. I did not like the way he treated his parents. I think that just rubbed me the wrong way.

As I said earlier the prose is beautiful. The language is quiet. It paints pictures so clearly without hitting you over the head with it. I could see the places they lived, the trains they travelled on, the parties they hosted. I felt like I was in all those places. Yet I found it difficult to connect with the passivity of the characters at times. There lack of communication with each other. It bothers me, maybe that is my own cultural bias but the fact that they never TALK to each other really rubbed me the wrong way. I guess what this shows is the difficulties when families grow up in different cultures. Ashoke and Ashima have certain expectations, expectations that their children do not. However, again, the not talking thing bothered me. My father didn’t grow up in Sweden, he comes from a culture that although similar is also very different. The way we avoid conflict is buy talking. I’ve heard stories about my dad growing up. I KNOW where he comes from because we talk about it. I just find it very hard to relate to characters that do not communicate. Again, maybe this is a failing of mine.

There were a couple of instances where I wondered if there weren’t mistakes in the writing. At one point we are told about Moushumi’s reaction to the break-up with Graham. We are told that she lives with friends. A chapter or so later Nikhil and Moushumi are at a party at the friends with whom she stayed, however this comes as a surprise to Nikhil. I just found it odd as I had understood it as we were told about Moushumi’s past at the same time as they discussed it. It seemed odd and it bothered me.

As always when my first encounter with a book is in audio I am left wondering if I would have had a different reaction to it had I read it. I will say that I really enjoyed the audio production. The narrator was clear and I liked how they used accents for Nikhil’s parents. It made the story feel more alive. It was read at a good pace but not to fast.

The book is told in somewhat of an episodic fashion; I wasn’t surprised to learn it had originally been a novella that had been expanded upon. This format makes it hard for me to see where the author is going at times. Although the story is told in chronological order it still feels very jumpy. Certain events that I felt had a big lead up were ended quickly, much like the ending of the book. They didn’t feel properly resolved, but rather they were just dropped without any real resolution.

Overall the book wouldn’t be my first choice for a Lahiri book, I preferred Interpreter of Maladies, but I wouldn’t discourage people from reading it. I never wanted to abandon it, I was invested enough in the characters that I wanted to find out what happened to them.

Purchase The Namesake from BookDepository


Copyright ©2010 Zee from Notes from the North.clip_image001This post was originally posted by Zee from Notes from the North. It should not be reproduced without express written permission.


Susi (The Book Affair) said...

I completely agree with you. I love Jhumpa Lahiri - I absolutely adore her and her writing style. But for me, she does it better in her short stories than she did in this novel. I still loved the novel, but I still prefer her short story collections. Have you read 'Unaccustomed Earth'? Just as great as 'Interpreter of Maladies'. Do read it! :)

brizmus said...

I ADORED this book! Like you, I thought the writing was utterly beautiful.
I actually liked this SO MUCH MORE than her short stories, though. I oddly enough didn't have any of the same problems that you have.

Anonymous said...

I've yet to read any Jhumpa Lahiri, but I'm starting to feel I should really try to get my hands on one of her books as soon as possible. I think I'll try to read Interpreter of Maladies first though.

Amanda said...

I still want to give this a try, but I"m sorry it was a disappointment to you. BTW, I was one of the kids in class doing the pre-emptive "that's me" too, not because of my first name, but because my last time is ridiculously unknown in this country and doesn't look at all like it's spelled.

Zee said...

Susi~~I haven't read Unaccustomed Earth but it is on my TBR list.

Brizmus~~It is a good thing we don't always have the same taste :). I think I had very high expectations on the book and that might have been part of my problem.

Iris~~I definitely recommend Interpreter of Maladies. We read it for class last year and I LOVED it. So beautiful.

Amanda~~Definitely give it a try! It isn't a bad book. As I said I think I might have had to high expectations.

Aarti said...

I am exactly the same way as you! I started this, but couldn't finish it. I think Lahiri is way better in short story format as well- I much preferred Interpreter of Maladies to this one.

Nymeth said...

I'm a bit scared to pick this up because everyone keeps telling me it's not as good as her short stories. It sounds like it's still worth reading, but I'll pick up The Unaccustomed Earth first.

Jade @ Tasting Grace said...

I keep coming across Lahiri, but I've never read any of her work. Though, reading your description of her book, I'm pretty sure I've seen the movie version of this. (I'm so bad, I really don't remember for sure.) Would you recommend anything in particular of hers?

Zee said...

Aarti~~I am so glad someone else felt the way I did about this book. It was starting to worry me that I had somehow missed something.

Nymeth~~I think it is definitely worth a read but I wouldn't put it on the top of the pile :)

Jade~~I would read Interpreter of Maladies which is a collection of short stories. It is really beautiful and doesn't have any of the problems this book did.

Jade @ Tasting Grace said...

Thanks for the suggestion! I'll definitely check it out.